"Excuse me, what?" Olive's lived through some pretty weird circumstances for a while now, and she knows, logically, that vampires do exist. She's never had a run-in with one before, but they're out there. This, though, is so utterly unexpected that she doesn't know how to process it, and for a moment, she's convinced she's heard wrong.

But she remembers something once said about secrets and how fast Bekah's moved and how she slammed that guy into the wall, and putting it all together makes her feel a little woozy, but she has no cause to disbelieve her either. "Oh, my God. Wait, seriously? I mean, not that I think you're lying, but... jeez."